VCU News Center

The Big Three and the Fate of the U.S. Auto Industry

Tom Gresham
(804) 221-0528
VCU Communications and Public Relations
(804) 828-6051
tmgresham@vcu.edu

4/27/2009

“Things have just fallen apart,” says George Hoffer, professor of economics at VCU and an auto industry researcher for more than 40 years.

The American automobile industry, specifically the “Big Three” companies of General Motors, Ford and Chrysler, has suffered deeply during the current recession. In fact, Hoffer says the American auto industry soon will be smaller than GM alone was about 30 years ago. A national debate continues on the industry’s future and the wisdom of contributing federal money to a recovery effort.

The American auto industry’s troubles are obvious, but Hoffer points out that other automakers, such as Japan’s Toyota and Honda, are also struggling in the current downturn and that they have made many of the same mistakes, such as an over-emphasis on building large vehicles. However, the American industry has been losing competitive ground for many years, making it particularly vulnerable to the recession.

Hoffer has researched the American auto industry’s loss of market share with his colleagues Edward Millner, professor and chair of the economics department at VCU, and Oleg Korenok, assistant professor of economics. Their research indicates that American auto companies have not kept up with their foreign cohorts in recognizing that “new product sells.”

“Japanese brands and to a lesser extent European brands have been much more aggressive in restyling and much more aggressive in introducing new products and that, according to our research, virtually explains over the last 15 years the decline in market share,” Hoffer says.

Hoffer says the auto industry needs another messiah vehicle, such as the SUV, to stage a comeback. Hoffer defines a messiah vehicle as one that already is in production but with one small alteration becomes hugely popular, allowing automakers to charge much higher prices to customers than the vehicles cost to make. Their popularity is often unpredictable to the automakers. Hoffer says the industry has had five or six messiah vehicles in the past 60 years.

“It’s going to come but I don’t see right now where it’s coming from,” he says.

Hoffer says the vaunted cultivation of green technology in vehicles will not give the industry the jolt it needs because the technology is still too far away to have a significant impact.

Without a messiah vehicle, the dream scenario that Hoffer envisions for a robust comeback involves – surprisingly – the stringent fuel economy standards that will debut in 2011. In his sequence of events, the economy first enjoys a speedy recovery this year, gas prices remain low and demand picks up among consumers. Then, with the present tooling of SUVs and pickup trucks and the high margins of those vehicles, the auto companies market to the American public the idea that these will be the last American vehicles of their kind ever made – and the public responds and flocks to snap them up.

“That would be the quickest way to a turnaround,” Hoffer says.

About George Hoffer
George Hoffer, Ph.D., professor of economics at VCU, has researched the automobile industry for more than 40 years and is one of the country’s top industry experts. Hoffer has worked for the U.S. auto industry, the import industry and for auto dealers and has written more than 70 articles on auto industry research.

Related videos

VCU Professor Says Economic Recovery Likely Will be Slow and Difficult

Uncertainty and volatility have gripped financial markets in the United States and likely will reign for years to come as the country struggles to regain its economic footing, according to Cory Bunting, associate director of the Capital Markets Center in the VCU School of Business.

View video

VCU Professor Sees Hope in Developments in Egypt

Van Wood, Ph.D., the Philip Morris Chair of International Business in the VCU School of Business, believes that there are significant reasons to believe that the toppling of the Mubarak regime in Egypt among widespread street protests will result in positive economic developments for both the Arab and Western worlds.

View video

VCU Professor Says Employment Picture Improving Slowly But Problems Loom

Improvements in the employment picture have been slow, but long-term complications are the larger concern, according to Robert Trumble, professor of management and director of the Virginia Labor Studies Center at VCU.

View video

Banking Industry Regulation Carries Both Risks and Rewards, VCU Professor Says

The Obama administration’s proposal to limit the size and risky activity of banks makes sense in its intent, but the current proposal could hamper banks’ economic development capabilities and consumer services, according to Kenneth Daniels, professor of finance at VCU.

View video

VCU Expert Sees Stressful Holiday Retail Season Ahead

Holidays are always a critical time for retailers, but this year’s holiday shopping season looms especially large because of broader economic concerns, according to David Urban, professor of marketing and interim dean of the VCU School of Business.

View video

Key to emerging strong from the recession is innovation, according to VCU expert

Businesses that invest in innovation during the economic recession are most likely to emerge from the downturn the strongest, according to Kenneth Kahn, Ph.D., professor of marketing and director of the da Vinci Center for Innovation in Product Design and Development at VCU.

View video

VCU history professor considers Great Depression causes and lessons learned

This month marks the 80th anniversary of the stock market crash recognized as the start of the Great Depression. And while the Great Depression is best remembered for the economy misery caused worldwide in the 1930s, its root causes happened much earlier according to John T. Kneebone, associate professor, Department of History.

View video

Fashion retailers cutting costs and inventory amid the economic crisis

The economy has been in crisis for some time now, but Karen Videtic, chair of the Department of Fashion Design and Merchandising at Virginia Commonwealth University, says that clothing retailers are just adjusting now, and consumers can expect big changes on the sales floor.

View video

VCU Chair Urges Retailers to Focus on Customer Service

Retail expert David Urban, Ph.D., chair of the Department of Marketing in the VCU School of Business, says that recessions tend to highlight every problem area that a retailer has – from operating inefficiencies to knowledge of their consumers.

View video

Economic Crisis Highlights Risk Management’s Importance to Lifespan of a Business

Risk management is not a flashy business topic – after all, making money is more exciting than saving it. Still, managing risk and avoiding problems is every bit as critical to the health of a business as creating revenue, according to a VCU professor.

View video

VCU Branding Expert Says Businesses Should Display Strength

The economy is limping badly, and many consumers are suffering. Kelly O’Keefe, a branding expert and the executive education director at the VCU Brandcenter, believes businesses have a responsibility to project strength and assume a leadership role in such an uncertain climate. However, most businesses are responding to the crisis with conspicuous trepidation, he says, thereby missing an opportunity to connect with customers.

View video

Job Loss Jitters?

It’s hard not to worry when newspapers, TV newscasts and the Web are filled with stories about layoffs, the stock market, foreclosures and shrinking retirement accounts. Fears about losing a job and paying bills in a declining economy can lead to sleepless nights, but taking action before a potential job loss can help you stay calm and healthy, according to Micah McCreary, Ph.D., a professor in the VCU Department of Psychology.

View video

Back to top